What Four Experimental Beers Taught Me About Brewing

Written ByDiego Santiago

Last updated

Of all the experimental beers I’ve brewed, my favorite started with a mash full of marshmallows. It was a pastry stout we made together at Chaneque and Yeccan. We put the marshmallows right into the mash, and there’s a photo from brew day that shows just how many we used.

Before that stout, I’d already brewed with Oaxacan tamales, pushed a beer under 4% ABV to an on-paper target of 1,000 IBUs, and made a smoked porter with tobacco leaf. Each one began with a question I wanted to answer by brewing it.

What happens when you brew with Oaxacan tamales?

The first thing I had to do was unwrap the tamales. The corn husks came off, and I had to figure out what the tamales themselves would do in the mash.

The fat was the part that demanded the most attention. I had to think carefully about how I handled the grain bed so the wort could still run through it. “Let’s make a tamale beer” had sounded like a flavor idea. On brew day it became a question about how to get the wort out of the mash tun.

That’s one of the things I like about brewing with food. I start by thinking about what I want to taste. By the time I brew, I’m also thinking about what that ingredient will do to the process I rely on.

How far could I push hops in a beer under 4% ABV?

I set out to make a beer under 4% ABV, with softened water and a target of 1,000 IBUs on paper. I wanted a low-alcohol beer where I could focus on how the hops came across.

Bags of hops steep in green, hoppy wort in a stainless kettle on the 1,000-IBU brew day. The number captures how far I wanted to push the recipe. What I wanted to learn was in the glass. How would the hop character come through in a beer that light? How long would the bitterness stay with me after a sip? Those were the questions that made the batch worth brewing.

The smoked porter that pushed my curiosity further

I also made a deeply smoky porter with tobacco leaf. At the time, I was curious about the combination of smoke, nicotine, and alcohol. It was one of the more extreme ideas I tried, and it made me think more carefully about where I draw the line when I experiment. Tobacco contains nicotine, which can be toxic if swallowed (Poison Control). I’d keep tobacco out of beer today.

The marshmallow stout I’d brew again

My favorite was that Chaneque × Yeccan pastry stout. Marshmallows are easy to picture next to a dark, dessert-inspired beer. What made the idea fun was putting them in the mash together and seeing what happened on brew day.

Two hands raise glasses of Chaneque and Yeccan beer in front of the brewery's stainless tanks. It’s the batch I come back to because of the collaboration. There’s a particular joy in pitching an odd idea to another brewer and hearing them say, “Let’s try it.” I can still look at that photo and remember how much fun it was to make.

Follow our collaborators on Yeccan Cervecería’s Instagram.

Why I keep experimenting

What I love about making beer is having the freedom to follow an idea all the way through. Sometimes that means unwrapping tamales and rethinking the grain bed. Sometimes it means sharing a mash tun with another brewery and throwing in more marshmallows than either of you would buy on an ordinary day.

That freedom is part of what makes independent brewing a movement as well as an industry. A macrobrewery has to make the same beer taste the same at enormous scale. At Chaneque, I can brew a batch because I’m curious and because another brewer wants to find out with me. That’s a kind of freedom I don’t think a macrobrewery can reproduce at its scale.

When a batch starts with a “what if,” write down what you were trying to find out. Then record what actually happened on brew day and what you tasted. Try Foambyte® for free to keep the recipe, brew-day notes, and tasting observations together.

Sources

Related blog posts you may like

Brew day tracking in Foambyte beside a stainless steel brewing vessel with amber wort in its sight glass.
Diego Santiago

Brew Day Tracking: Why Every Detail Matters

Brew day tracking turns mash temperatures, timings, gravity and volumes into useful records. Learn what to log and how to improve your next batch with Foambyte.

Learn MoreLearn More
Brewer pouring a beer sample from a stainless steel fermenter valve to check a high final gravity
Diego Santiago

Why Is My Final Gravity Higher Than Expected?

Your beer stopped bubbling, but the gravity is still higher than expected. Is fermentation stuck, or is your beer actually finished? Let's explore what might be happening and how to avoid the same problem in your next batch.

Learn MoreLearn More
Brewing water chemistry illustration showing beer, brewing water minerals, gypsum, and calcium chloride salts
Diego Santiago

How Water Affects Beer: Brewing Water Chemistry

Learn why water matters in beer and how Foambyte helps you choose the brewing salts needed for your target water profile.

Learn MoreLearn More